| Scholastic Bowl All-Conference Teams |
| 2023 All-Conference Team
1st Team Corbin Tutterow - Southwestern Logan Simmons - Gillespie Sam Horn - Litchfield Max Eldred - Staunton Charlie Wilson - Carlinville 2nd Team Noah Manasco - Vandalia Alexander Sticha - Hillsboro Tomas Cottingham - Carlinville Kennedy Dempsey - Southwestern Blake Moore - Staunton 3rd Team Wyatt Akers - Southwestern Keaton Jones - Vandalia Zach Leitshuh - Litchfield William Mann - Greenville Saul Quiroz - Hillsboro Camden Walker - Greenville |
| 2022 All-Conference Team
1st Team Spencer Hoehl - Litchfield Ashton Seniker - Southwestern Joseph Siegfried - Staunton Logan Simmons - Gillespie Corbin Tutterow - Southwestern 2nd Team Dale Brandon - Southwestern Blake Moore - Staunton Katie Peppler - Greenville Eli Ratcliff - Carlinville Alexander Sticha - Hillsboro 3rd Team Wyatt Akers - Southwestern Ryan Baugher - Litchfield Tomas Cottingham - Carlinville Kennedy Dempsey - Southwestern Levi Hatley - Gillespie Anna Jackson - Hillsboro |
| 2021 All-Conference Team
1st Team Brigid Dunn – Carlinville Spencer Hoehl – Litchfield Emma Nord – Greenville Ashton Seniker – Southwestern Corbin Tutterow – Southwestern 2nd Team Tad Daniels – Hillsboro Tommy DeVore – Hillsboro Tori Harston – Carlinville Chloe Horn – Litchfield Logan Simmons – Gillespie 3rd Team Dale Brandon – Southwestern Katie Peppler – Greenville Emily Smith – Southwestern William Yurick – Southwestern |
| 2020 All-Conference Team
1st Team Chloe Beckert - Greenville Spencer Hoehl - Litchfield Reagan Kulenkamp - Carlinville Shelby Oertel - Southwestern Rachel Watson - Southwestern 2nd Team Dale Brandon - Southwestern Charlie Gibbel - Carlinville Katie Reed - Gillespie Ashton Seniker - Southwestern Corbin Tutterow - Southwestern 3rd Team Joe Bertetto - Gillespie Emma Nord - Greenville Blake Rentz - Litchfield |
| 2019 All-Conference Team
1st Team Alexa Huber - Hillsboro Reagan Kulenkamp - Carlinville Carter Moore - Southwestern Joel Nord - Greenville Luke Tutterow - Southwestern 2nd Team Eli Atkins - Hillsboro Tyler Behme - Carlinville Tommy DeVore - Hillsboro Sydney Hoehl - Litchfield Ethan Matthews - Greenville Evan Oakley - Greenville Shelby Oertel - Southwestern Grace Traylor - Carlinville Rachel Watson - Southwestern 3rd Team Colin Caveny - Gillespie Spencer Hoehl - Litchfield Alex Jasper - Gillespie Olivia Peters - Greenville Blake Rentz - Litchfield Peyton Smith - Southwestern Charles Wright - Gillespie John Wyatt - Gillespie |
| 2018 All-Conference Team
1st Team Grayson Armour - Carlinville Joel Nord - Greenville Jacob Simmons - Southwestern Lana Kay Tutterow - Southwestern Robert Wiggins - Carlinville 2nd Team Grace Draper - Southwestern Sydney Hoehl - Litchfield Carter Moore - Southwestern David Munshaw - Greenville Andy Towner - Litchfield Luke Tutterow - Southwestern |
| 2017 All-Conference Team
1st Team Ava Armour - Carlinville Jake Miller - Gillespie Jacob Simmons - Southwestern Colin Thomas - Litchfield Jonathan Tutterow - Southwestern Lana Kay Tutterow - Southwestern 2nd Team Grayson Armour - Carlinville Nick Breitweiser - Southwestern Erin Caveny - Litchfield Marshall Hatley - Gillespie Shruthi Mekala - Hillsboro Jennifer Seth - Hillsboro Luke Tutterow - Southwestern |
| 2016 All-Conference Team
1st Team Kaeden Kessinger - Southwestern Jacob Klenke - Greenville Andrew Riddle - Greenville Jacob Simmons - Southwestern Colin Thomas - Litchfield Michael Tofte - Carlinville 2nd Team Ava Armour - Carlinville Jake Martin - Gillespie Lucaas Secrist - Hillsboro Jonathan Tutterow - Southwestern Noah Wafford - Pana Ashley Washburn - Litchfield Brandon Wyatt - Southwestern 3rd Team Stephen DeMartini - Gillespie Ethan Harbert - Pana Chris Storm - Hillsboro |
| 2015 All-Conference Team
1st Team Andrew Thomas - Litchfield Kaeden Kessinger - Southwestern Andrew Riddle - Greenville Michael Tofte - Carlinville Kinder Guthrie - Litchfield 2nd Team Darby Jones - Southwestern Matt Healey - Carlinville Jacob Klenke - Greenville Jake Martin - Gillespie Kyle Towner - Litchfield 3rd Team Nichole Miller - Gillespie Ethan Harbert - Pana |
| 2013 All-Conference Team
1st Team Kyle Sottoriva - Carlinville David York - Litchfield Jonathon Montgomery - Southwestern Tyler Ziemba - Greenville Spencer Daigle - Litchfield 2nd Team Kaeden Kessinger - Southwestern Austin Lytle - Gillespie Allison Groves - Carlinville Mandy Jourdan - Vandalia Cassidy Jones - Southwestern Trevor Guntren - Hillsboro 3rd Team Andrew Thomas - Litchfield Davis Humphreys - Carlinville Mitch Armour - Carlinville Taylor Sronce - Carlinvlle Darby Jones - Southwestern Logan Plummer - Pana Hayden File - Greenville |
| 2012 All-Conference Team
1st Team David York - Litchfield Kyle Sottoriva - Carlinville Jonathan Montgomery - Southwestern Katie Pollman - Greenville Woody Stanfield - Marquette Catholic 2nd Team Anh Nguyen - EAWR Trenton Meyer - Carlinville Brayden Helgen - Litchfield Mandi Jourdan - Vandalia Spencer Daigle - Litchfield Jordan Fox - EAWR Trevor Guntren - HIllsboro Cassidy Jones - Southwestern Tyler Ziemba - Greenville |