| Boys Soccer All-Conference Teams |
| 2022 All-Conference Team
1st Team Will Meyer - Carlinville - Goalie Asher Barbre - Carlinville Gavin Norwood - Carlinville Tyler Summers - Carlinville Judah Liss - Greenville Will Christian - Hillsboro Adison Pollard - Hillsboro Logan Murray - Hillsboro Drake Gasperson - Litchfield Nate Fetter - Litchfield Luke DeWitt - Staunton 2nd Team Mitchell Lowe - Hillsboro - Goalie Matt Dunn - Carlinville Paeton Brown - Carlinville Nolan Tabor - Greenville Aidan Andris - Greenville Griffen Hughes - Hillsboro Hunter Payne - Hillsboro Nico Clark - Hillsboro Jaiden Johnson - Litchfield Jackson Pierce - North Mac Adam Overby - Staunton Arda Gencel - Vandalia 3rd Team Joshua James - Greenville - Goalie Brady Harris - Carlinville Matt Reiher - Carlinville Ivan Powell - Greenville Mitchell Cunningham - Hillsboro Mark Mattson - Hillsboro Kyle Butler - Hillsboro Anthony Bader - Litchfield Raymond Schneider - North Mac Ashton Copeland - Staunton Mihir Patel - Vandalia |
| 2006 All-Conference Team
Cathey - EAWR Gibson - Marquette Catholic Marian - Marquette Catholic Mussatto - Gillespie Chris Walker - Carlinville - Goalie 2nd Team Treece - Litchfield Carlisle - EAWR Thomack - Litchfield S. Walker - Carlinville Korte - Marquette Catholic Chris Strohbeck - Carlinville Tarro - Gillespie Pfeifer - Roxana Podwojski - Staunton Ruyle - Carlinville Wetzel - Hillsboro Kratschmer - Marquette Catholic Delaney - Marquette Catholic Mulholland - Greenville Pohlman - Carlinville Talkington - Roxana Paynic - EAWR Rauzi - Gillespie - Goalie Honorable Mentions Poirot - Litchfield Cochran - Litchfield Roberts - Marquette Catholic Leeds - Marquette Catholic Brackman - Staunton Arbuthnot - Roxana Lutz - Hillsboro Buerkett - Hillsboro Nolker - Greenville Lubrant - Gillespie Ruyle - Gillespie |
| 2004 All-Conference Team
1st Team Brian York - Greenville Deigo Gamino - Greenville Danny Gibson - Marquette Catholic Jacob Fuchs - Marquette Catholic Cody Gerdes - Staunton Josh Leach - EAWR Kyle Rufus - Hillsboro Mike Moseley - Staunton Bierim Ibraimi - Greenville Cory Kasten - Marquette Catholic Logan Jones - Keeper - Marquette Catholic 2nd Team Darryl Hinckley - Litchfield Jacob Schiemper - Greenville Michael Gibson - Hillsboro Matt Grabner - Marquette Catholic Matt Walker - Carlinville Walt Kinney - Vandalia Marcus Mussatto - Gillespie Tyson Birk - Carlinville Matt Cathey - EAWR Eric Heyen - Litchfield Andrew Craig - Keeper - Greenville Honorable Mentions Joe Young - Carlinville Mike Ruyle - Carlinville Tyler Bianco - Staunton Dan Podwojski - Staunton Eric Wood - Litchfield Leif Brockman - Roxana Ben Settle - Roxana Jordan Chiles - Hillsboro Jermel Liddel - Hillsboro Frank Cuevas - Gillespie Travis Gucciardo - Gillespie Adam Tarro - Gillespie Gabe Emerick - Vandalia Michael Owens - EAWR |
| 2003 All-Conference Team
1st Team Nick Certa - Marquette Catholic John Barth - Greenville Matt Wickenhauser - Marquette Catholic Diego Gamino - Greenville Anthony Obernuefermann - Gillespie Thomas Duncan - EAWR Luke Vidakovich - Marquette Catholic Tyler Adams - Greenville Mike Moseley - Staunton Matt Carmody - Marquette Catholic 2nd Team Danny Armstrong - Carlinville Kyle Saxby - Litchfield John Reid - Carlinville Cody Gerdes - Staunton John Weaver - Marquette Catholic Brian York - Greenville Matt Hainaut - Staunton Colin Sievers - Gillespie Jake Fleming - EAWR Dan Sumner - Roxana Chad Warner - Greenville Honorable Mentions Jacob Fuchs - Marquette Catholic Jimmy Siatos - Marquette Catholic Walt Kinney - Vandalia Gabe Emerick - Vandalia Nathan Loucks - Hillsboro Cory Downer - Roxana Aaron Archibee - Carlinville Brad Pirok - Staunton Sean Treese - Litchfield Brian Dern - Gillespie |