| Softball All-Conference Teams |
| 2007 All-Conference Team - SCC West
1st Team Pitcher Chelsea Boente - Carlinville Leslie Davis - Southwestern Kelcie Matesa - Gillespie Catcher Sydney Shelton - Southwestern First Base Kristin Holtorf - Southwestern Jessica Tiek - Gillespie Second Base Brittany Zehr - Gillespie Shortstop Melissa Gray - Southwestern Brandy Nasello - EAWR Third Base Jenny Meckles Utility Infielder Megan Williard - Southwestern Outfielder Jamie Janssen - Gillespie Christy Jones - Southwestern Jena Kronable - Marquette Catholic Utility Outfielder Brianna Markel - Roxana Designated Hitter Katie Trombetta - Southwestern Honorable Mention Pitcher Bernadette Heneghan - Marquette Catholic Catcher Lara Vonnahmen - Marquette Catholic Utility Infielder Randi Martin - Gillespie Outfielder Danielle Ash - Carlinville Sarah Trombetta - Southwestern Designated Hitter Ali Goodman - Carlinville |
2007 All-Conference Team - SCC East
1st Team |
| 2006 All-Conference Team - SCC West
1st Team Pitcher Leslie Davis - Southwestern Amanda Hill - EAWR Kelcie Matesa - Gillespie Jane Ruppert - Marquette Catholic Catcher Sydney Shelton - Southwestern First Base Leah Carter - EAWR Second Base Leah Emerick Shortstop Jenny Meckles - Marquette Catholic Third Base Megan Williard - Southwestern Utility Infield Melissa Gray - Southwestern A.J. Jackson - Roxana Outfield Christy Jones - Southwestern Brianna Markel - Roxana Mary Millitello - Marquette Catholic Utility Outfield Shae Anderson - Roxana Sarah Trombetta - Southwestern Designated Hitter Maddie Newcomb - Marquette Catholic Honorable Mention Catcher Lara Vonnahmen - Marquette Catholic First Base Randi Eveans - Roxana Second Base Samantha Boucher - Southwestern Third Base Erica Bess - Roxana Utility Infield Jessica Tick - Gillespie Designated Hitter Chelsea Boente - Carlinville | 2006 All-Conference Team - SCC East |
| 2004 All-Conference Team - SCC West
1st Team Pitcher Kim Hoffmann - Roxana Dylan Mathis - Roxana Jessica Wiedman - Marquette Catholic Catcher Bridget Ruppert - Marquette Catholic First Base Lindsey Marcuzzo - Roxana Second Base Leah Emerick - EAWR Amie Tillery - Roxana Shortstop Mary Wiedman - Marquette Catholic Third Base Jenny Meckles - Marquette Catholic Utility Infielder Maleah Phillips - Carlinville Outfielder Ashley Dively - Roxana Heather Haney - Southwestern Kara Memiszewski - Marquette Catholic Utility Outfielder Dana Spurgeon - Carlinville Designated Hitter Jessica Wolff - Southwestern Honorable Mention Pitcher Amanda Hill - EAWR Catcher Michelle Fuller - Roxana First Base Emily Huebener - Marquette Catholic Shortstop Jordan Davis - Roxana Third Base Megan Williard - Southwestern |
2004 All-Conference Team - SCC East
1st Team Pitcher Megan Garrison - Greenville Amber Redman - Hillsboro Sarah Tarter - Litchfield Catcher Michelle Otto - Vandalia First Base Dana Rigor - Staunton Second Base Kelli Shelton - Hillsboro Shortstop Meredith Banal - Vandalia Jennifer Bitter - Litchfield Third Base Ashley Slatton - Greenville Brittany Krueger - Staunton Utility Infielder Crystal Stevenson - Greenville Rhe Anne Semlar - Litchfield Designated Hitter Outfielder Nichol Edgar - Greenville Nikki Ginos - Hillsboro Natasha Butler - Hillsboro Honorable Mention Catcher Jenny Rogers - Litchfield First Base Elizabeth Clay - Vandalia Second Base Outfielder Rebecca Shaw - Litchfield Jenny McMillen - Pana Utility Outfielder Elise Elliott - Greenville Kelli McMillen - Pana |