| Team CaptainsSouthwestern Football |
| 1971 |
Bill Bates & Gary Foiles |
| 1973 |
Bill Gibson, Malcomb Foiles & Joe Fedrick |
| 1990 |
Shawn Davis & Matt Hasquin |
| 1993 |
'93 Seniors |
| 1994 |
Jesse Stuckey & Jared Childress |
| 1995 |
Gary Gray, Ted Sancamper, Craig Pruett & Dennis Tucker |
| 1996 |
Terry Starks, Nic Beilsmith & Dave Saffell |
| 1997 |
Chris Brands & Matt Kitzmiller |
| 1998 |
Neil Owens & Nic Strohbeck |
| 1999 |
Sam Powers, Jerad Pruitt & Brandon Stephens |
| 2000 |
Sam Byndom, James Musgrave, Dan Strohbeck & Eric Wagener |
| 2001 |
Luke Lahr, T.J. Huber, Rusty Kruse & Darrell Sheets |
| 2002 |
Josh Reno, Aaron Bowman & Shawn Buchanan |
| 2003 |
Josh Chism, Jake Harrington & Brandon Rigsbey |
| 2004 |
Adam Stanton, Jason Jackson & Tony Maronie |
| 2005 |
Nick Albrecht, Todd Cunningham, & Shane Nance |
| 2006 |
Brandon Avery, Kyle Lincoln, & Josh Savage |
| 2007 |
Michael Fisher, Jacob Gray, & Justin Miller |
| 2008 |
Steven Bedell, Brent Harrison, & Adam Wallace |
| 2009 |
Ryan Cox, Ryan Gray, & Cole Hagen |
| 2010 |
Joe Vellella, Steven Jones, Jimmy Greene, Nick Skjerseth |
| 2011 |
Michael Hoxsie, Zach Mansfield, Steven Fritsch |
| 2012 |
C.J. Couch, Walter Mitchell, Brandon Robinson, Nick Simmons, Jimmy Barnett |
| 2013 |
? |
| 2019 |
Logan Anderson, Adam Bates, Jack Davis, Payne Hubbs, Algenon Wilson |
