Southwestern football
| 1999 | Sam Powers |
| 1968 | Kenny Schrier |
| 1964 | Tom Kahl |
| 1963 | Larry Stewart |
| 1962 | Sam Kahl |
| Special Mention | |
| 1967 | Ken Schrier |
| Honorable Mention | |
| 2020 | Ashtin Sorgea - IHSFCA 3A & News Gazette Defensive Line |
| 2002 | Josh Reno |
| 1999 | Brandon Stephens |
| 1967 | Ed Baker |
| 1967 | Randy Childress |
| 1967 | Randy Reno |
| 1967 | Dave Sample |
| 1967 | Don Shanks |
| 1967 | Larry Summers |
| 1967 | Paul Tonsor |